PGR: Survey Results Analyzed

Thu 2nd Jun 2016 - 8:20pm : Gaming

By Luis "Suar" Suarez, @PG_Suar

The Numbers Game

Following the release of the PGR Top 50, members of the community are starting to wonder more about the inner workings of the system and its occasionally controversial, though objective, results. With 15 regions represented, 48 panelists consulted, and over 35 tabs in a very packed Excel Sheet, there are many conclusions to be drawn from the data that was researched.

Notably, the survey that was given to over 50 people from around the world yields some pretty eye-opening data.

50 names were drawn out for the survey from high placings at the 22 tournaments that were researched. All the usual suspects that either won or placed top 4 at a tournament were immediately noted and written into the survey -- namely ZeRo, Nairo, and Dabuz.

As old tournament brackets were dusted off and we delved deeper and further into top 8, top 16, and top 32, many names started to come about that we were anticipating.

After pruning the list of inactive members, one-time showings, and other outliers, a preliminary Top 50 list was created and sent off to surveyors around the world.

In order to be as inclusive as possible, we reached out to members of the community in every active Smash community that we could find. Whether they were content creators, TOs, or competitors, we wanted the opinions of anyone we could ask. With a majority of the surveyed residing in North America, we made special efforts to contact those in Japan, Mexico, Europe, and Australia.

The instructions were simple: Give a rating on a scale of 1-10 with 1 being the weakest and 10 being the strongest and 0 being a “skip” option. Those who were surveyed that were also on the survey itself were asked to rate themselves at 0. After a 2 week process of sending out the survey and following up with the panelists through many different mediums and languages, we officially closed the survey and started studying the numbers we received.


The Results

With nearly 2,400 pieces of data, we organized all of the ratings into a spreadsheet in order to run tests.

One of the first things we did was gather all of the averages of the ratings for each name on the list and then we calculated the associated standard deviations. The standard deviation is a measurement of how differently people voted. The higher the SD, the more people voted all over the place. For example, some people voted MVD very high (10) and others very low (3) so MVD’s ratings have a high standard deviation while almost everyone voted ZeRo at 10 so he has a standard deviation close to 0.

We felt that it was imperative to include this measure since it shows by how much the opinions of the panelists varied on any given name. We found that the most controversial players had the highest SDs, while the shoe-ins, like ZeRo, had extremely low SDs.

The SD shows the difference between all the values and the average that was found for each player. The larger the SD, the greater the variability in the opinions. Conversely, the lowest standard deviations were associated with opinions that did not vary much at all.


The Highs

The Mexican Terror, Leo, had the highest SD of any player ranked on the PGR. With a bold 19th finish on the PGR, he also touted a SD of 2.05 and an average rating of 7.9. We figured that such a high variance in his ratings can be attributed to the fact that previous to GOML 2016, Leo had absolutely no North American tournament attendance. However, his rating was so high because many felt that his 1st place dominance of so many tournaments in Mexico for so long had to be reminiscent of a godlike player coupled with the fact that he eliminated the likes of Mr. R and Vinnie.

Following in second, Mr. ConCon had a SD of 1.87 and an average score of 6.67. Given his history-making set win over ZeRo, this SoCal local has garnered much support but also many dissenters. While many pinned it to being a fluke, others recognize that Mr. ConCon is a tournament threat and respect his dedication to Luigi despite the nerfs. Regardless, a lack of a tremendous impact at majors have left many doubting his ability which is reflected in the spread of his ratings.


Static Manny’s results landed him with the 3rd highest SD of 1.74 and an average score of 6.86.  A Tampa native, Static Manny won many regionals in Florida and also made a decent appearance in the beginning of the scene, but trailed off towards the beginning of 2016. This, combined with other Sonic mains such as 6WX and Komorikiri taking the spotlight left many of the surveyors skeptical.


Many other players that had high SDs, such as iStudying and Nick Riddle, had some sort of high octane situation that brought them to the community airwaves, but either did not follow up and deliver a second showing or left many disappointed by not improving in the way they thought they should.


The Lows

As many can imagine, there was only 1 ranking in the entire PGR that was incontestable - number 1. With a SD of .15 and an aggregate score of 9.98, the 48 surveyed overwhelming gave ZeRo a 10/10 with only 1 or 2 opinions dropping down to a 9. Unsurprising, given ZeRo’s historic track record in Smash 4 today.


Second to ZeRo is the Japanese threat Abadango. Settling in with a SD of .70 and an average score of 9.17, Abadango definitely set a name for himself in the Western Hemisphere with a 1st place finish at Pound 2016. Even though Abadango has a wild time in Japan along with the other Japanese smashers that place in and out of top 8 at events, Abadango has consistently seized top 8 finishes in American tournaments. The community will never forget his Mewtwo rolling over everyone in McLean, Virginia at Pound 2016.


After Abadango, Dabuz had the 3rd lowest SD value. At .74, Dabuz placed 3rd on the PGR with a survey rating of 9.64. Coincidentally, Dabuz has always been the third name to be included in sentences that start out with, “ZeRo, Nairo, and ... “. Consistent in Tristate and always in and around top 8 at nationals and majors, Dabuz has unquestionably always been the next best player after ZeRo and Nairo. Getting consistently eliminated by only the Top 5 but eliminating everyone else has the community placing Dabuz at 3rd in their heads and in the survey.


Honorable mentions are Mr. R and ANTi, SDs of .77 and .88 respectively. Surprisingly opinions on ANTi did not vary a considerable amount despite his absence at tournaments where many expect him to be. Mr. R, on the other hand, has been a consistent international threat and his impressive itinerary boasts impressive results worldwide and, thus, high opinions. Also both players being Brawl veterans also draws a level of favorability that others on the list did not always have.


Of course, we did not want this survey to be the only metric by which we rank players on the PGR so, instead, we relied on data derived from placings and set counts from the 22 tournaments we researched since Apex 2015.


For example, Dabuz was 1 place higher on the survey list than on the objective list and Nairo was 1 spot lower on the survey list from his spot on the objective list. While historically Nairo has always been regarded as the next best player after ZeRo with several tournaments wins and even two sets over ZeRo, which Dabuz does not have, a 49th place finish (Pound 2016) can explain a dramatic amount of panelists not favoring Nairo over Dabuz. Nairo’s survey score was 9.50 and Dabuz’s aforementioned 9.64 trumps it by only .14 -- this bias is important to realize when current events can be related to people’s perceptions of the top players.


Thus, the X Factor was perhaps the most important quantitative measure to have come about from the survey since it was able to relate the bias of the panelists to the factual data we found. High X Factors and low X Factors will always tell a different story depending on the player, but it will definitely be something that will stay with the PGR for many iterations to come.



Alan Bunney M.D.

Your Comments

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:06pm

    An incredibly interesting examine, I may possibly not concur entirely, but you do make some very valid points.lifestyleabout

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:05pm

    Hello fellow web master! I really enjoy your site! I liked the color of your sidebar.thepetsabout

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:05pm


    *You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!petrefine
  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:05pm

    Aw, this is quite a nice post. In concept I have to put in place writing such as this additionally – taking time and actual effort to produce a really good article… but so what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means manage to get something done.truehealthyfacts

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:04pm

    Register a domain, search for available domains, renew and transfer domains, and choose from a wide variety of domain extensions.homeimprovementall

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:04pm

    A domain name name, or Web address, is an deal with where it is easy to be observed online. It’s how you’ll communicate yourself by means of email or your site and it’s which buyers assume of once attempting to discover you.entertainmentbee

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:04pm

    Thanks for your post. One other thing is when you are disposing your property all on your own, one of the problems you need to be aware about upfront is just how to deal with house inspection accounts. As a FSBO supplier, the key about successfully shifting your property in addition to saving money in real estate agent commission rates is knowledge. The more you realize, the smoother your sales effort might be. One area in which this is particularly important is inspection reports.theshoppingpack

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:03pm

    Hi, if you want to get higher rankings, you should check out the plugin I left in my link, it will help.itscurrentfashion

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:03pm

    I have observed that over the course of making a relationship with real estate proprietors, you’ll be able to get them to understand that, in every real estate financial transaction, a payment is paid. In the end, FSBO sellers will not “save” the commission rate. Rather, they fight to earn the commission by simply doing a good agent’s work. In accomplishing this, they devote their money and also time to execute, as best they might, the responsibilities of an broker. Those tasks include revealing the home by way of marketing, introducing the home to prospective buyers, building a sense of buyer emergency in order to make prompt an offer, organizing home inspections, dealing with qualification check ups with the loan company, supervising repairs, and facilitating the closing.thesportshint

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:02pm

    I keep listening to the news update lecture about receiving free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best site to get one. Could you advise me please, where could i get some?itsportshub

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:01pm

    I can’t say that I completely agree, but then again I’ve never really thought of it quite like that before. Thanks for giving me something to think about when I’m supposed to have an empty mind while trying to fall asleep tonight lol..purehomeimprovement

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:01pm

    I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I’m quite certain I will learn plenty of new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!themoviesbio

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:01pm

    hello good site i will definaely come back and see again.happylifestyletrends

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:00pm

    i could only wish that solar panels cost only several hundred dollars, i would love to fill my roof with solar panels-gettechexpert

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 12:00pm

    I admire your piece of work, regards for all the interesting posts .geteducationskills

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 11:59am

    I besides believe therefore , perfectly composed post! .travelbudgetonline

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 11:59am

    After research a couple of of the weblog posts in your website now, and I really like your method of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website record and will probably be checking back soon. Pls check out my site as effectively and let me know what you think.growhealthexperts

  • Wed 13th Jan 2021 - 11:58am

    Some really helpful information in there. Why not hold some sort of contest for your readers?dailybusinessguide

  • Tue 12th Jan 2021 - 3:17pm

    I found Hubwit as a transparent s ite, a social hub which is a conglomerate of Buyers and Sellers who are ready to offer online digital consultancy at decent cost. polskie kasyno online

  • Tue 12th Jan 2021 - 2:09pm

    I have express a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorite’s blog site list and will be checking back soon… avukatlık hizmetler

Please register or login to post comments